top of page
Family with their catch on the dock at Key Largo Fisheries after a Coastal Dreams fishing charter

Reef vs. Offshore Fishing in Key Largo: Which Charter Is Right for Your Group?

5 hours ago
4 min read

The most common question we get when someone calls to book is simple: should we do a reef trip or go offshore? Both are great, and both leave from the same dock in Key Largo. The right choice depends on who's in your group, what you want to catch and how much time you have. Here's how they compare.



The quick answer

  • Choose a reef trip if you have young kids or first-timers, anyone worried about seasickness, or you want steady action and fish to take home for dinner.

  • Choose an offshore trip if your group wants big fish like mahi, tuna, wahoo or sailfish, and is comfortable spending more time running and trolling between bites.

  • Can't agree? A longer trip lets the captain mix both on the same day, conditions permitting.



What is reef fishing in Key Largo?

Key Largo sits next to the only living coral barrier reef in the continental United States. Reef and wreck fishing happens about 3 to 4 miles offshore in 35 to 200 feet of water, so the ride is short and you spend most of your time fishing.


After catching live bait each morning, Captain Bunky and the crew drift, bottom-drop, chum, kite-fish and troll. Typical targets include yellowtail and mutton snapper, grouper when in season, kingfish, cobia, barracuda, African pompano and sharks, with the occasional wahoo or sailfish. Captain Bunky's crew once boated a mutton snapper just 6 ounces shy of the world record, so you never know what's down there.


Reef trips are good year-round and are our top pick for families. The action tends to be steady, kids can reel in fish themselves, and the inside waters are usually calmer than the Gulf Stream.


Captain Bunky's crew holding a mutton snapper just 6 ounces shy of the world record on a Key Largo reef trip


What is offshore (deep sea) fishing in Key Largo?

Offshore means heading past the reef into deep blue water and the Gulf Stream. This is where you find pelagic gamefish: mahi mahi, blackfin tuna, wahoo and sailfish. We don't just troll and hope. We look for birds, weed lines and floating debris, sight-pitch live baits and troll rigged ballyhoo.


Seasons matter more offshore. Peak mahi and blackfin tuna season is March through September. Sailfish season is November through March, when we fish the reef edge 3 to 7 miles out. For the biggest challenge, the daytime swordfish trip runs about 25 miles offshore to fish 1,500 to 2,000 feet deep.


Offshore days involve more running and some waiting between bites, followed by big, fast action when you find the fish.


Two anglers holding a pair of wahoo in the cockpit of Coastal Dreams on a Key Largo offshore charter


Reef vs. offshore, side by side

  • Distance: reef is about 3 to 4 miles out. Offshore ranges from the reef edge for sailfish to about 25 miles for swordfish.

  • Main fish: reef means snapper, grouper, kingfish and more. Offshore means mahi, tuna, wahoo and sailfish.

  • Action: reef is steady with lots of bites. Offshore has fewer bites, but bigger fish.

  • Best season: reef is year-round. Offshore depends on the species (mahi March through September, sailfish November through March).

  • Kids and first-timers: reef is easiest. Offshore works best for kids who are older and comfortable on a boat.

  • Seasickness: reef is usually gentler. Offshore can be bumpier when the wind blows.

  • Fish to take home: both. Snapper are a reef favorite for dinner, and mahi and tuna make great fillets.



Trip lengths and prices

Every Coastal Dreams trip is private for your group of up to 6, with bait, tackle, licenses, ice and fish cleaning included. Current prices on our charters page:


  • Reef and bottom fishing: half day (4 hours) $1,300, 3/4 day (6 hours) $1,600, full day (8 hours) $1,900.

  • Offshore: half day (4 hours) $1,400, 3/4 day (6 hours) $1,700, full day (8 hours) $2,000.

  • Sailfish and pelagic: half day $1,400, full day $2,000.

  • Daytime swordfish: 10 hours, $2,700.


Half days run 7 to 11 AM or 12 to 4 PM. Gratuity is not included. Full-day trips booked 45 or more days out can be paid over time with a $500 deposit.



Our recommendations by group

  • Families with young kids: a morning half-day reef trip. You're back by 11 AM, before the afternoon heat.

  • Mixed group, first time in the Keys: a 3/4-day trip, so the captain has time to fish the reef and push offshore if conditions are right.

  • Experienced anglers: a full-day offshore trip in mahi season, or a full sailfish day in winter.

  • Bucket-list fish: the 10-hour daytime swordfish trip.


Not sure? Call 239-758-0253 and we'll recommend the best trip for the season, tides and weather. You can also read our month-by-month guide to fishing Key Largo.



About Coastal Dreams

Captain Bunky Leach is a USCG-licensed captain (six-pack OUPV) and a longtime Florida Keys billfish specialist. He fishes from Key Largo Fisheries at MM 100, ocean side, aboard the 41' Luhrs Coastal Dreams, which has an air-conditioned salon and a bathroom below. Groups are capped at 6 anglers, the maximum under a six-pack license, so every trip is private.


Read more about Key Largo reef fishing charters and Key Largo deep sea fishing charters. Staying farther down the Keys? We also book partner captains in Islamorada, Marathon and Big Pine Key.





Frequently asked questions

Is reef or offshore fishing better for kids?

Reef fishing is usually better for kids. The ride is short, the water is often calmer, and steady bites keep them busy. A morning half day is a great first trip.


How far offshore do Key Largo fishing charters go?

Reef trips fish about 3 to 4 miles out. Sailfish trips work the reef edge 3 to 7 miles out, and daytime swordfish trips run about 25 miles offshore. On other offshore trips, it depends on where the fish are that day.


Will I get seasick?

Reef trips are usually gentler than offshore trips. If you're prone to seasickness, take motion sickness medicine before the trip, choose a reef trip, and pick a day with light winds.


Can we keep the fish we catch?

Yes, within Florida's size and bag limits. The crew will fillet and bag your keepers at the dock. Bring a cooler to take them home.


Do we need fishing licenses?

No. Fishing licenses are included for every angler on board Coastal Dreams.


How many people can come?

Up to 6 anglers. That's the limit under the captain's USCG six-pack license, and it keeps every trip private.


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page